Propello
All posts

Should Your Brand Expand to Walmart, eBay, or TikTok Shop?

Jason Carter · · 3 min read

Short version: most brands should add Walmart next. TikTok Shop fits if your product is visually demo-able and under about $40. eBay only as a liquidation channel.

Here’s the breakdown.

Walmart Marketplace

The case for Walmart:

  • Less saturated than Amazon. Walmart’s marketplace has roughly 100,000 active sellers vs. Amazon’s 2M+.
  • Higher average order value in most categories.
  • Walmart is investing heavily in marketplace growth, including ads and fulfillment.
  • Walmart’s buyer skews older, higher household income, and more loyal to retailers.

The friction:

  • Approval is slower than Amazon. Most brands take 2–8 weeks to get approved.
  • Walmart Connect (ads) is less mature than Amazon Ads.
  • Fewer third-party tools, less rich data than Amazon.

Best fit: established brands with stable Amazon presence that want a less competitive channel with higher AOV. If you sell on Amazon and Walmart doesn’t carry you yet, you’re missing a real revenue stream.

TikTok Shop

The case for TikTok Shop:

  • Discovery-driven. Buyers find products through video, not search.
  • Works well for impulse buys and gift-giving categories.
  • The algorithm can put a small brand in front of millions of viewers in 48 hours.
  • Conversion happens in-app. No friction redirect.

The friction:

  • Fee structure is steep (roughly 5–8% commission plus shipping costs).
  • Returns run higher than Amazon, often 15–25%.
  • Lives by the algorithm. A viral product can sell out in a day, then the next week it’s dead.
  • You need video content, either your own or from creators. Static product photos won’t move.

Best fit: visually interesting products under $40 with broad appeal. Beauty, home accessories, pet products, kitchen gadgets, fashion accessories. Not a fit for B2B, high-consideration items, or anything that needs detailed specs.

eBay

The case for eBay:

  • Works for refurbished, collectible, and end-of-life inventory.
  • Lower barrier to entry than Amazon or Walmart.
  • 132 million active buyers, mostly an older audience.

The friction:

  • Margins are thin. Final value fees plus managed payments stack up.
  • Buyer price expectations are low. eBay shoppers expect a discount.
  • Listing quality bar is low, which makes the channel feel stale to most brand owners.

Best fit: brands using eBay as a liquidation channel for excess inventory, not as a primary growth lever. If you’re building a premium positioning, eBay is the wrong storefront.

How to decide

A few questions to ask:

Are you scaled on Amazon yet? If you’re not consistently moving $50K+/month on Amazon, you usually don’t have the operational bandwidth or inventory turnover to make a second channel pay off. Get one channel right first.

Is your product visual? TikTok Shop only works for products that show well in a 30-second video. If your product needs explanation, it won’t perform there.

Do you have channel-specific assets? Each channel needs its own listing, images, and often pricing. If you can’t invest in dedicated content, the channel will underperform.

Can you control distribution? Adding channels without MAP enforcement means your existing Amazon resellers may start undercutting Walmart, or vice versa. Have your distribution policy figured out before you add the channel.

The capital question

Each new channel costs inventory. Inventory ties up cash. A brand running thin on working capital is better off going deeper on Amazon than spreading across three channels and being out of stock on all of them. Pick the channel that gives you the highest return on the capital you have, not the one that sounds most exciting in a board meeting.

For most brands in 2026, that’s Walmart.